Big Business, Poor Peoples: The Impact of Transnational Corporations on
the World's Poor
by John Madeley
London: Zed Books, 1999
206 pages; $19.95
Most treatments of global poverty fail to analyze the role of multinational
corporations in perpetuating the plight of the world's poor. Journalist
John Madeley has written a useful introductory critique of corporate involvement
in developing nations, drawing on extensive travel experience and the
work of non-governmental organizations (NGOs).
Madeley examines the impact of multinationals in various economic sectors:
agriculture, forestry, fisheries, mining, manufacturing, pharmaceuticals,
energy and tourism. He explains how the multinationals exploit natural
resources at the expense of local communities and, because much of the
work is now done through local sub-contractors, with little accountability
or financial risk to the global corporations themselves.
The size and reach of multinationals sets them apart from national firms.
Pressures from international financial institutions, trade organizations
and international financial markets severely inhibit Third World governments'
ability to design their own development strategies that attempt to keep
foreign companies at bay.
Madeley examines how tobacco and other corporate products aggravate poverty
by diverting scarce money from food and other essentials. While tobacco
companies hook governments on tax revenues, they put a costly strain on
public health budgets. In developing nations, tobacco cultivation also
disrupts village culture, placing an extra burden on women (who have to
gather extra fire wood for curing), and degrading the land. Other multinational
corporate products, including baby foods and food grown for export, cause
similar kinds of disruption.
A valuable chapter explores the corporate colonization of the United
Nations, first through the U.S.-led dismantling of the UN Center on Transnational
Corporations, then by corporations gaining "special status" within development
agencies such as the Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO). Corporations
have used their growing influence in agencies like the FAO to make themselves
the chief beneficiaries of aid programs, another way they fleece the poor.
Such is corporate power that it seems unlikely that a meaningful general
code of conduct on multinationals could ever be negotiated, or implemented
if it were negotiated - though such a code was high on the UN agenda in
the 1970s and into the 1980s. Talk in the 1990s of international regulation
is largely in terms of protecting multinationals' interests rather than
those of developing countries - with agreements such as the Multilateral
Agreement on Investment.
Madeley notes that despite the multinationals' power, they remain dependent
on people, especially in rich countries, using their technologies and
buying their products. He highlights numerous means of curbing corporate
power, including specific product codes of conduct (e.g., for infant formula),
and focuses briefly on examples where governments have stood up to multinationals
on specific rules regarding their own resources, including Namibia's fishing
policies and the Philippine government's mining policies. He also encourages
governments to hire ex-corporate employees who know the tricks of the
trade, and to enact national codes of conduct restricting multinationals
from operating in more than one economic sector.
Ultimately, grassroots economic activities are a key factor in resisting
multinational corporate encroachment. Farmers who produce milk to replace
imported brands, consumers in richer countries who buy equitably produced
merchandise, shareholder activism and the development of North-South NGO
ties are all a necessary means of developing resistance to multinational
corporate power.
Madeley is no blind optimist. Conditions are grim and getting worse.
He finishes his balanced, but short treatment of this vast topic by suggesting
that large multinationals are inherently incompatible with just and ecologically
sound societies. Like so many analyses of corporate power, Big Business,
Poor Peoples leaves readers knowing they have a lot of work ahead.
Reclaiming America
by Randy Shaw
Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999
312 pages; $16.95
Randy Shaw takes many of the lessons from his previous book, The Activist's
Handbook, and applies them in Reclaiming America to three progressive
struggles of the 1990s - the campaign against sweatshop labor abuse, the
campaign for tougher air pollution laws and efforts to redirect the federal
budget from Pentagon bloat to social needs.
Shaw's main point is that in an age of corporate globalization, national
and international campaigns must have a strong grassroots base to succeed
against powerful corporate opponents.
Reclaiming America first discusses how a small group of labor rights
activists built a campaign against Nike's use of sweatshop labor. Nike
became a natural target not because it was the first corporation to increase
profits by moving its plants overseas, but because of its vision of a
world where sweatshops are seen as essential components to economic growth.
Nike's heavy investment in promoting its image made it susceptible to
a deft media campaign conducted by a loose coalition of human rights workers,
student groups, religious groups and union activists. Along with domestic
anti-sweatshop campaigns targeted at Jessica McClintock, Inc. and Guess
jeans, anti-Nike activists crystallized opposition to socially irresponsible
economic globalization around an easily understood core idea: a living
wage for all workers.
By creating the infrastructure necessary for connecting locally focused
activists and organizations to the national arena, the Sierra Club and
the Public Interest Research Groups (PIRGs) have also built a model for
national activism that can be applied to other progressive campaigns.
These two groups built field operations in local communities, which allowed
them to mobilize citizens in order to win stronger new Clean Air Act amendments.
Not all campaigns in the 1990s have succeeded in mobilizing a national
movement around issues affecting local groups. The effort to redirect
federal spending from defense spending to social needs has suffered from
the lack of a mobilized grassroots base. Shaw suggests that this is partly
because many community-based organizations (CBOs) have devolved from organizing
to service centers.
An astute chapter on the media looks at contemporary issues such as what
it means to organize in the face of increased fragmentation of consumer
media choices and problems caused when the progressive media is not connected
to the movements they cover.
While acknowledging the value of e-mail as a relatively cheap organizing
tool to build far-flung networks and provide minute-by-minute updates,
Shaw cautions activists about relying too much on the internet.
Overall, Reclaiming America is a rigorous movement analysis for progressive
activists and organizers across the United States.
- Charlie Cray
|